A Catholic apologetics & formation system.
About Fideograph Help
Create Account

Verdict: Historically Refuted

Did Augustine teach that God positively predestines some souls to damnation, as Calvin later taught?
Augustine taught that God actively predestines the elect to salvation but only permissively allows the reprobate to fall. Calvin's double predestination is…
Historically Refuted
Was the doctrine of the Trinity invented at the Council of Nicaea, or was it defined against a heretical novelty (Arianism)?
Arius was the innovator, not the Council. Triadic baptismal formulae, doxologies, and theological language appear throughout 2nd and 3rd century sources. Nicaea…
Historically Refuted
Did the early Church use Scripture alone as its rule of faith, without appeal to Tradition or an authoritative teaching office?
Irenaeus explicitly argues against heretics who claimed to use Scripture — his criterion of orthodoxy is apostolic Tradition preserved in episcopal succession,…
Historically Refuted
Are papal claims to universal jurisdiction and infallibility medieval inventions with no basis in the early Church?
Every element of what Vatican I defined in 1870 can be found in embryonic or explicit form in sources from before AD…
Historically Refuted
Did the key Reformation doctrines (Sola Fide, Sola Scriptura, symbolic Eucharist, rejection of purgatory) have support in the early Church Fathers?
Luther himself acknowledged that his doctrine of Sola Fide had no explicit patristic support. The Reformers' solution was to claim the Church…
Historically Refuted
Does Scripture teach that Scripture alone is the sufficient authority for Christian doctrine?
No biblical text teaches Sola Scriptura. 2 Timothy 3:16–17 says Scripture is profitable — not that it is the only authority. Luther…
Historically Refuted
4 sources AD 1521–present
Petrine Ministry
The Petros/Petra distinction in Greek does not exist in the Aramaic Jesus spoke
The Protestant argument that Jesus called Peter a small stone (Petros) while building on a different rock (petra) collapses completely in the…
Historically Refuted
Scripture & Tradition
"The early Church held that Scripture alone — without Sacred Tradition or the Church's teaching authority — was the sufficient rule of faith."
The New Testament canon itself was determined by the Church using Tradition — not by Scripture using itself. If Sola Scriptura were…
Historically Refuted
7 sources AD 180–397

History has always been on her side.

Explore verified claims across seven centuries of Church history.

Enter the Archive